This study highlights that marital violence has a significant impact on household expenditure, unpaid household production and care work, absenteeism and presenteeism of women and men, and wage employment of women in the State of Palestine.
In total, the State of Palestine lost in 2018 a minimum of $36 million or a maximum of $45 million due to violence against women. These include out-of-pocket costs, loss of productivity and unpaid household production and care work. The cost of violence against women in 2018 is equivalent to spending made by the World Food Programme in 2019; this includes $41 million to provide food security and nutrition to 343,000 persons in the West Bank and Gaza. 22,193 women were prevented from working and/or forced to quit work by their husbands. If these women join the workforce, wage employment would increase by 50 per cent.
Six in 10 currently married women reported experiencing at least one form of violence by their husbands in 2018. In the Gaza Strip, 7 out of 10 of currently married women reported having experienced any form of violence in 2018. In the Gaza Strip, the percentage of women who experience multiple forms of marital violence is double the percentage of women in the West Bank who experience multiple forms of marital violence. Violence is more prevalent among younger women compared to older women.
During 2018, women survivors of violence who report incurring out-of-pocket costs incurred costs equivalent to 12 per cent of their non-food expenditure, which amounts to a minimum $20 million and at maximum $29 million per year nationally. In the Gaza Strip, the average annual out-of-pocket cost is lower ($129), but is equivalent to 17 per cent of the non-food expenditure of survivors, as compared to the average annual out-of-pocket expenditures for survivors in the West Bank ($243), which is equivalent to nearly 12 per cent. In 2018, women survivors of violence experienced a productivity loss of nearly 173,000 workdays and their husbands’ productivity loss reached 128,000 workdays. The total productivity loss amounts to about $9 million. In 2018, women survivors of violence missed 259,000 days while their husbands missed nearly 42,000 days of unpaid household production and domestic work nationally. This amounts to $2.3 million annually.
Violence against women is a pervasive problem that cuts across cultural and religious barriers. World
Health Organization global estimates indicate that one in three women experience some form of
physical and/or sexual violence, perpetrated predominantly by a partner or ex-partner, over their
lifetime.
It is widely acknowledged that violence against women and girls has multiple impacts that translate
into losses for women, families and communities/businesses, as well as macro losses for society.
The specific objectives of the study are as follows:
● Direct costs – expenses associated with seeking health care and legal services, consumption costs related to repairing/replacing property, transport costs, expenses/bills; ● Indirect costs – impact on household chores (woman and spouse) and unpaid care work, missed schooldays, income loss due to missed paid/unpaid work (woman and spouse), women’s presenteeism, lack of women’s participation in wage employment.
● Household level costs; ● Costs due to productivity loss; ● Costs due to survivor’s low participation in wage employment.
As with all aspects of daily life, gender relations and dynamics are influenced by the ongoing
occupation, leading to differential impacts on women, men, girls and boys. 32 In addition to restricting
women and girls’ access to basic services and opportunities, Israeli checkpoints and policies reduce
their access to a secure livelihood and deny them the right to protection of the family unit, particularly
in the West Bank and Gaza.
Violence against women and girls, predominantly a consequence of entrenched patriarchal norms and
traditions, and a lack of progress in legislative reforms, poses a significant challenge to gender
equality in the State of Palestine.
Palestinian women also experience various forms of violence related to the occupation; for example,
ever married women and girls are exposed to violence at Israeli checkpoints, with 3.3 per cent
reporting psychological violence, 0.6 per cent physical violence and 0.2 per cent sexual violence in
2011.
The Violence Survey in the Palestinian Society, 2019 is the third nationally representative survey on violence. It is also the first to include questions on the economic costs of marital violence. Conducted between 13 March – 20 May 2019, the survey consisted of eight main sections, including one focused on currently or ever married women aged 18-64. Drawn from a total sample of 11,545 households across the West Bank and Gaza Strip, there were 5,114 currently or ever married women.
Out-of-pocket (OOP) costs were estimated for women who reported any form of violence in the last 12 months. They include costs incurred by survivors in accessing health and legal services, replacing property and other financial costs.
Loss of unpaid household production, in the form of domestic work and care work for children and the elderly because of marital violence in the last 12 months was estimated. Due to their violence against their wives, husbands may stop doing domestic and care work, and their lost days have also been estimated.
Productivity loss is estimated for both survivors and their husbands.
Female labour force participation in the State of Palestine is among the lowest in the world (21.6 per cent) with a 2020 study indicating gender discrimination in the labour market in terms of opportunities and wages. 72 This study has attempted to associate low wage employment of survivors with marital violence and decision-making about the nature of their wage employment.
Approximately six in 10 currently married women reported experiencing at least one form of violence by their husbands in the last 12 months, with 22.7 per cent reporting physical and/or sexual violence.
Overall, one in four (25.2 per cent) currently married women experiencing marital violence in the last 12 months reported incurring some OOP expenditure.
The average OOP expenditure incurred by survivors of marital violence in the last 12 months amounted to $184.30. The average yearly per capita non-food expenditure in the State of Palestine is $439.10. This implies that 25.1 per cent of marital violence survivors who incurred some OOP costs spent, on average, 11.8 per cent of their yearly non-food expenditure on these.
Nearly 6 per cent of currently married women experiencing violence in the last 12 months reported missing childcare for 9.2 days, resulting in 292,254 days when survivors could not take care of their children.
A small percentage of currently married women experiencing violence reported that their husbands missed approximately 4.4 childcare days, resulting in approximately 46,451 days lost nationally.
This study highlights that marital violence has a significant impact on household expenditure, unpaid household production and care work, absenteeism and presenteeism of women and men, and wage employment of women in the State of Palestine.
The most direct effect on household expenditure arises from the fact almost one in four survivors incurred some OOP costs, equivalent to an average 11.8 per cent of their yearly non-food expenditure. Such inflated expenditure could be much better utilized on such items as children’s education, household leisure activities and gifts for family members. It is significant that marital violence unquestionably affects the ability of women to do care work, which is integral to the overall contribution women make to wider society and the economy. Crucially, while survivors missed about 260,000 care workdays nationally, their husbands also missed approximately 42,000 care workdays. A woman’s care workday is about triple (6.63 hours) that of men (2.65), implying that women, in hourly terms missed considerably more care work-hours. This has important consequences in the current pandemic, which has led to both an increase in marital violence and care work for women. This study also points to the impact of marital violence on economic activity in terms of loss through absenteeism and presenteeism. The almost equal impact of women and men’s absenteeism (100,336 days versus 88,640 days) must be interpreted with caution, given women’s low labour force participation. It is important to keep in mind the high number of missed workdays reported by women – on average 23 days of paid and unpaid work. Further, husbands also missed work due to marital violence against women. Though a relatively small group, those who do miss work do so for a significant number of days (on average, nine unpaid days). On presenteeism, a dimension of productivity loss rarely measured in violence research, we see much higher levels among women, the reported days much higher than for men. Violence has significant impacts on women’s productivity at the workplace, potentially seriously affecting their employment stability, earnings and future occupational mobility, all factors that contribute to the continued gender wage gap in the State of Palestine. Perhaps the study’s most important finding is in establishing female’s low wage employment due to marital violence and the effect on a woman’s decision-making about the nature of their own wage employment. Based on sensitivity analysis, there is significant potential to increase women’s wage employment by a minimum 41 per cent and as high as 52 per cent. Given data limitations, this impact cannot be easily monetized but the analysis suggests that an increase in women’s wage employment could be sizeable and have profound impact on the economic production of the State of Palestine.
This study has demonstrated that continuing marital violence is costly for Palestinian women and their families, the economy and society. The key recommendations are as follows:
The Council of Ministers should approve the draft law on violence against women and girls at the earliest opportunity to ensure efforts to align with SDG 5, including eliminating marital violence, are prioritized.
At a minimum, the Palestinian Government should establish a dedicated budget for violence prevention and response, allocating sufficient resources to scale up current efforts.
Provide monetary support for survivors of marital violence to access violence services.
Ensure an understanding of the wider impacts of marital violence to guide the development of the new national strategy, to be underpinned by a whole-of-government, holistic approach.