Simply select any text on the page to have your computer read it to you.
Choose the preferred Text to Speech accent from your available system voices.
Child marriage is a human rights violation and a development challenge that impedes progress
towards the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development. The elimination of this practice is at the
heart of concerted efforts by ESCWA, UNICEF, UNFPA, and UN Women, who are jointly committed to
tackling this issue. They have spearheaded a series of studies examining the economic
repercussions of child marriage in the Arab region. The initial study, "Estimating the cost of
child marriage in the Arab region: Background paper on the feasibility of undertaking a costing
study," sheds light on the severe consequences of this practice. It offers insights into the
extent, causes, and impacts of child marriage in the region and emphasizes the importance of
quantifying its economic costs. This paper underscores the urgency of eradicating child marriage
to promote gender equality, empower women, and improve maternal and child health.
The second study in the series entitled “The cost of child marriage over the life cycle
of girls and women: Evidence from Egypt, Iraq, Jordan and Tunisia” delves into the life-cycle
costs associated with child marriage, assessing its effects across different stages of a woman’s
life. Focused on Egypt, Iraq, Jordan, and Tunisia, the study reveals the far-reaching and
profound effects on women’s health, education, and economic status, thereby enriching our
understanding of the long-term strain caused by this harmful practice. This piece of research
not only quantifies the costs of child marriage on human development but also provides a roadmap
for its economic evaluation.
The third and latest study, “Estimating the economic costs of child marriage in the
Arab region," expands on previous findings by conducting a more detailed demographic, health and
economic analysis. This comprehensive report highlights the significant impact of child marriage
on the region's economy, estimating a potential increase of about 3 percent per annum to the
Arab region's economy, amounting to approximately $3 trillion (US dollars) between 2021 and 2050
if child marriage is eliminated. The failure to address this issue, on the other hand, would
lead to substantial economic challenges.
Together, these studies present a compelling narrative about the extensive and varied
economic implications of child marriage in the Arab region. Each successive study contributes to
a deeper understanding of this critical issue, advocating for thorough and effective policy
interventions to combat this pressing social problem. These reports collectively underscore the
necessity for comprehensive action, including improvements in family planning, healthcare,
education, and labor market opportunities for women, to prevent child marriage and mitigate its
detrimental economic impacts in the region.
Evidence from Egypt, Iraq, Jordan and Tunisia
Background Paper on the Feasibility of Undertaking a Costing Study
The present report for computing the economic costs of child marriage in Arab economies was
collaboratively developed by the United Nations Economic and Social Commission for Western Asia
(ESCWA), the United Nations Population Fund Arab States Regional Office (UNFPA ASRO), the United
Nations Children’s Fund Middle East and North Africa Regional Office (UNICEF MENARO), and the
United Nations Entity for Gender Equality and the Empowerment of Women (UN-Women). Srinivas
Goli, Associate Professor at the Department of Fertility and Social Demography, International
Institute for Population Sciences (IIPS) in Mumbai, served as the Lead Consultant for this
report. Supporting Srinivas Goli were other researchers, including Harchand Ram, Shubhra Kriti,
Shalem Balla and Somya Arora from IIPS, as well as Neha Jain, Assistant Professor at the
Department of Economics, Indian Institute of Foreign Trade (IIFT) in Delhi.
The researchers would like to express their deep gratitude to Ruchika Chaudhary, Gender
Economist (Economic Affairs Officer) in the Gender Justice, Population and Inclusive Development
Cluster at ESCWA, for her supervision, continuous support and invaluable feedback throughout the
entire process, greatly enhancing the research. The study also benefited from the pertinent
contributions of Stephanie Chaban, Social Affairs Officer within the same cluster at ESCWA. Nada
Darwazeh, Chief of the Centre for Women at the Gender Justice, Population and Inclusive
Development Cluster at ESCWA, provided direction, with overall guidance from Mehrinaz El Awady,
the Leader of the Gender Justice, Population and Inclusive Development Cluster at ESCWA.
The report further benefited from the valuable insights and feedback provided by
external peer reviewers, including Aisha Hutchinson (King’s College London), Robert Bain (UNICEF
MENARO), Sajeda Amin (Population Council, New York) and Shatha Elnakib (Johns Hopkins Bloomberg
School of Public Health), whose perspectives greatly enriched the study.
Eliminating child marriage in the Arab region would have a significant positive impact on economic growth. It is estimated that it could boost the region’s economy by approximately 3 per cent per annum, adding a staggering $3 trillion between 2021 and 2050.
Failure to address the issue of child marriage will result in substantial economic burdens for the Arab region, even with advancements in other socioeconomic, demographic and health measures. If child marriage rates persist, Algeria, Jordan, the State of Palestine, Sudan and Tunisia are projected to experience the highest cumulative GDP losses between 2021 and 2050.
The prevalence of child marriage varies significantly across the region, with rates ranging from 1.5 per cent in Tunisia to 45.3 per cent in Somalia. Additionally, there are variations among provinces within each country. These variations underscore the crucial need for tailored policies and targeted interventions that effectively address and counteract the detrimental consequences of child marriage. Furthermore, Arab countries should strengthen their socioeconomic, population and health policies to mitigate the negative implications of child marriage on women.
Ending child marriage also requires addressing the underlying structural determinants of gender inequality, such as countering discriminatory norms, improving access to quality education, promoting economic participation, providing health-care services, and supporting initiatives to end violence against women and girls. Taking swift action to address these factors will result in greater economic benefits.
Arab countries can avert economic losses by prioritizing key channels, including promoting family planning and maternal and child health care to reduce high fertility and child mortality rates, ensuring access to education for girls both before and after marriage, and creating flexible labour market opportunities that encourage the active participation of women in economic activities.
Child marriage remains a prevalent global practice, with around one in five girls marrying
before the age of 18 in 2022. A considerable variation can also be seen across countries. Child
marriage has been shown to have lifetime consequences for girls in terms of poor educational,
health and economic outcomes, depriving them of their basic rights and leaving the next
generation at a disadvantage. The issue has been aggravated by the COVID-19 pandemic and demands
effective and conscious intervention, especially in the poorest countries that exhibit the
highest rates of child marriage. Despite a declining trend in child marriage, the current rate
in the Arab region remains sizeable, with a wide variation across countries. While the
prevalence of child marriage across the Arab region has dropped from one in three to one in five
females, progress has stagnated over the recent decade. A growing volume of studies are
increasingly demonstrating the negative effects of child marriage on a variety of developmental
outcomes; however, concerted efforts and resources to neutralize the practice remain inadequate
across the Arab region. To stimulate greater efforts towards eliminating child marriage, the
present study underlines the economic costs of child marriage and the key mechanisms for a
number of Arab countries. The report offers essential insights into the economic consequences
(cost of inaction) if child marriage is neglected in Arab countries. It serves as valuable
material for advocacy efforts, aiming to draw governments’ attention to this pressing problem.
Economic costs are channelled through demographic, social and health implications
generated as a consequence of child marriage. Demographic implications comprise unwanted
pregnancies and unsafe abortions that alter future population growth, mother and child survival,
and reproduction. Social implications comprise the loss of educational attainment by girls who
are married as children, which eventually harms the exercise of their basic rights, agency,
decision-making ability, earning prospects, community support and empowerment in general. Health
implications include adolescent pregnancies and births, and the high fertility and maternal
morbidity and mortality rates for women marrying early. These implications, endured by girls who
marry as children, might be direct or indirect, as well as monetary or non-monetary, for
individuals and households and cumulated at the State level.
The Phase I report, developed by ESCWA, UNFPA ASRO, UNICEF MENARO and UN-Women (2023)
and entitled “The cost of child marriage over the life cycle of girls and women: evidence from
Egypt, Iraq, Jordan and Tunisia”, studied the costs of child marriage borne by women and girls
in the Arab region. Building on the earlier report, Phase II of the study extends the findings
to measure the “economic costs of child marriage” for 13 of the 22 Arab countries for which the
relevant data is available. The study aims to report the economic costs of child marriage in
terms of the percentage of gross domestic product (GDP) loss for Arab countries. It also
theoretically discusses the multiple ways in which child marriage affects women and girls at the
individual level with repercussions on their families and thereby the State.
Building on earlier work and following a more robust procedure, the present report
utilizes a wider spectrum of demographic, health, education and economic input indicators in the
costing exercise, utilizing a life course perspective to project the economic cost of child
marriage in the Arab region up to 2050 with the base year of 2001. It covers the entire
productive timeline of a girl who married at the age of 15 around the year 2000. The data for
input indicators was compiled from multiple sources, primarily nationally representative
household surveys, including the Demographic and Health Survey, the Multiple Indicator Cluster
Survey and the Labour Force Survey.
Overall findings suggest that the percentage of GDP lost due to child marriage across 13
Arab countries in 2021 was 3.2 per cent and is expected to be 3 per cent in 2050. The cumulative
GDP loss is anticipated to stand at around $3 trillion between 2021 and 2050. Regionally, in
2021, Algeria, the State of Palestine, the Sudan and Tunisia showed more than 4 per cent of GDP
loss attributable to child marriage, while Qatar and the Syrian Arab Republic lost the lowest
GDP (less than 1 per cent). Between 2021 and 2050, Algeria, Jordan, the State of Palestine, the
Sudan, and Tunisia are estimated to lose the highest cumulative GDP attributable to child
marriage if current child marriage rates persist.
It is important to note that the economic cost of child marriage not only depends on the
rates of child marriage but also on the differences in demographic and socioeconomic outcomes
between females married below 18 years of age and those married at 18 and above. Therefore,
Algeria, Jordan and Tunisia will incur greater economic costs attributable to child marriage
because they have greater fertility and educational differences across females married below 18
years of age than those married at 18 and above. On the other hand, countries like Iraq and
Mauritania have higher child marriage prevalence rates, but the relative differences in
fertility rates and educational levels between those married below 18 years of age and those
married at 18 and above are not as high as in Algeria, Jordan and Tunisia, thus incurring lesser
economic costs that are attributable to child marriage.
Our estimate (3.2 per cent in 2021 for the Arab region) is higher than earlier studies
covering emerging and developing countries (1 per cent) and South Asia, the Middle East and
Africa (1.4 per cent). There could be two reasons for this discrepancy: (1) the difference in
the geographical coverage across all three studies; or (2) the difference in the procedure of
estimation and the number of input indicators considered for the model. The current study is
more comprehensive in terms of indicators inputted for the model. However, the total GDP
estimates across the 13 Arab countries from this study are in tune with the World Bank estimates
for the respective countries.
In terms of policy implications, the present study highlights that the extent of child
marriage significantly contributes to the failure of States in achieving their economic
potential. The variations in the economic cost of child marriage, measured by GDP loss, within
the Arab region stem from two key factors: the prevalence of child marriage and the
effectiveness of countries’ health-care and socioeconomic systems. It is imperative for Arab
countries to take action in preventing child marriage and mitigating the associated demographic,
health and economic impacts. By addressing critical channels such as promoting family planning
and maternal and child health care to reduce high fertility and child mortality rates, ensuring
access to education for girls before and after marriage, and creating flexible labour market
opportunities to encourage women’s participation in economic activities, countries can avert
economic losses.
Global literature on child marriage is heavily skewed towards social, demographic and health
implications. In particular, most of these studies have reported differences in health,
education and employment outcomes for girls married before and after turning 18 years old.
Few studies have documented the economic cost of child marriage, particularly the
macroeconomic costs (e.g. percentage of GDP loss due to child marriage). The literature
constraint is more significant for the Arab region than other regions of the world; thus, we
have utilized both global and Arab region studies to build conceptual and analytical
frameworks for the current study. We have organized the literature review into three
sections: (1) drivers of child marriage; (2) economic costs; and (3) child marriage in the
context of the Arab region.
Drivers: The documentation on child marriage consistently
highlights several structural factors that generate and intensify child marriage, ranging
from economic factors such as poverty and limited work opportunities; sociocultural factors
such as education, social practices, religious beliefs, ethnicity, class and gender norms;
and political factors such as instability, including conflict, displacement and natural
disasters. All these factors jeopardize a girl’s voice and autonomy, putting her in the loop
of early marriage and its eventual consequences. The poorest countries, regions and
households often confront the greatest prevalence of child marriage, with poor girls
residing in rural regions as the most vulnerable. Moreover, the lack of work opportunities
for girls due to social norms and practices may cause parents to consider it unnecessary to
invest in their schooling.
More often than not, as the growing evidence shows, the level of education tends to
determine a girl’s age at marriage; as such, lower education attainment is associated with a
lower age at marriage. Furthermore, child marriage has been demonstrated to be deeply
entrenched in social practices and traditions. Diverse settings serve as drivers for child
marriage that are prevalent in respective set-ups, notably the practice of dowry or bride
wealth, which can generate instant economic gains for a family; community pressure to
conform to societal norms; using the marriage of girls to settle family disputes; the fear
of sexual harassment or sexual violence; the desire to control girls’ sexuality to avoid
unwanted pregnancies or jeopardizing the family’s honour; and internalized social norms
whereby girls themselves desire to marry early due to perceived vulnerabilities and a lack
of alternatives.
Conflict and war impact women and girls in uniquely gendered ways, albeit varying
based on the location, earnings, social set-up and cultural setting. Conflict-induced
instability generates fear of injury and death, escalates incidents of sexual violence,
triggers food insecurity and deepens gender stereotypes. Such instability leads to a low
mean age for females at the time of marriage, higher child marriage rates and low female
literacy rates. For families in conflict zones, child marriage becomes a negative coping
mechanism to “save” the girl from perceived exploitation while conserving limited resources
by passing responsibility for her to another household. Child marriage, therefore, can be
interpreted as a social exchange of girls by the family to maximize their resources and
safety nets.
The economic costs of child marriage: Age at marriage is a
significant determinant of population dynamics, given that it sets the foundation for
forthcoming factors in deciding a girl’s quality of life. While child marriage is widely
addressed as a human and women’s rights issue, lately, studies have highlighted and
quantified the economic costs of child marriage (table 1).
The economic cost of violence against women and girls (child marriage, in this case),
defined in the UN-Women report “The costs of violence”, is the direct and indirect tangible
cost with a monetary value. These could be the private costs endured by young girls and
their next generation, or public costs such as an increased burden on the government’s
health-care and education systems. The total costs tend to have a multiplier effect on GDP
and economic development, triggering the vicious cycle of inter-generational poverty and
inequality.
Child marriage directly lowers women’s work prospects and financial returns due to
low educational levels. At the same time, it indirectly increases the proportion of their
unpaid household work resulting from higher lifetime fertility. To corroborate, Savadogo and
Wodon (2017a) found that child marriage reduces earnings in adulthood for women marrying
early by 9 per cent through its impact on education. In some countries, it has been noted to
affect decision-making and bargaining power.
Therefore, economic costs are the closest channels affecting the GDP of a State
through the low employment rate of women married as children, the low wage rate of their
unskilled jobs, and lower earnings, savings and hence a lower tax generation for the State.
Child marriage in Arab countries: Like many other regions in the
world, the Arab region has patriarchal norms whereby women are expected to prioritize their
family before their own rights as individuals.
This includes the institutionalization of policies that work to preserve the
patriarchal status quo that ultimately governs economic, political and social
decision-making.
In the past decade, conflict has tended to drive the many instances of child
marriage in the region, resulting in refugees and displaced families resorting to the
practice to protect girls from sexual violence and thus safeguard the family’s honour.
In some cases, child marriage is linked to kidnapping and trafficking by armed
groups and militias; the Syrian Arab Republic and Iraq have recorded such instances of the
abduction of girls.
In Jordan, child marriage incidents have increased since the onset of the conflict
in the Syrian Arab Republic in 2011, particularly among Syrian refugees. For example, the
rate of child marriage among Syrian girls in Jordan increased from 33.1 per cent in 2010 to
43.8 per cent in 2015, impacting their sexual and reproductive health in terms of untimely
pregnancies, domestic violence, social alienation, mental health issues and a loss of work
opportunities.
There is strong evidence of the relationship between child marriage and deep-rooted
cultural beliefs and discriminatory gender norms in the Arab region. For instance, in Egypt,
child marriage is linked with community notions related to female genital mutilation (FGM),
while in the Syrian Arab Republic, young girls are persuaded to marry at a young age due to
their sexual inexperience.
Poverty is another factor that engenders child marriage in countries such as Egypt,
Libya, Somalia, the Sudan, the Syrian Arab Republic and Yemen.
The trend is also noted in Iraq, Jordan and Morocco, where girls in low-income
families, viewed as a financial burden, were twice as likely to marry young than in
wealthier households in 2006–2011.
A study on Syrian refugees in Egypt highlights that underperforming girls in school
were better off married, and girls interested in education were retained in school to
continue their studies and had their marriages postponed.
Among other factors are a worsening economy and growing inflation rates that
negatively impact the survival of low-income families, particularly with young women, in
these regions.
Phase I of this exercise explored the costs of child marriage on women and girls in
four Arab countries and is the only comprehensive study that has highlighted the social and
health costs of child marriage at different stages of women’s lives. Women and girls who are
married young in Egypt, Iraq, Jordan and Tunisia experienced serious ramifications at each
stage of life in terms of fertility, decision-making, education, autonomy, labour force
participation and mortality rates of their children. Hence, Phase II builds on these
findings to focus on the loss of income (or GDP) for the Arab region.
In the Arab region, research has mainly
focused on examining the prevalence
of child marriage, identifying the social,
economic and political factors that drive
this practice, and investigating its harmful
effects on girls and women. While the
Phase I report established a link between
child marriage and various outcomes
related to demographics, health, education
and the labour market, it did not quantify
the economic losses that result from this
practice for the State. To gain a better
understanding of the actual short- and
long-term economic costs that women,
their families and the Government will bear,
it is crucial to evaluate the impact of child
marriage on the GDP of all Arab countries.
Therefore, the goal of this study is to
conduct a cost analysis that measures the
impact of child marriage on the GDP of
countries, with the aim of strengthening
the case for eradicating this practice
in the region. The study advances
recommendations to reduce the economic
burden of child marriage by taking
proactive steps to address the intermediate
channels that contribute to economic
implications.
The present study employs the spectrumbased
simulation model and incorporates
a wide range of input indicators to provide
a detailed analysis of the demographic,
social and macroeconomic costs
associated with child marriage. Unlike
Mitra and others (2020), the present
study does not rely solely on a macroregression
model approach. Instead, its
hierarchical and component simulation
approach enables the inclusion of more
input parameters and the estimation of
a larger number of outcome indicators.
Moreover, the model used in the study not
only projects the cost of inaction on child
marriage as a percentage of GDP loss but
also includes other key demographic and
health indicators up to 2050, covering the
entire productive lifespan of a girl who was
married at age 15 around the year 2000.
Child marriage incurs economic costs through multiple channels, as depicted in figure 1. This practice has demographic implications such as high fertility levels, early childbirth and population growth, which directly impact economic outcomes. Child marriage also disrupts educational attainment, leading to limited decision-making ability, particularly in terms of reproductive choices, instances of gender-based violence against women and low labour force participation, resulting in poor health status and low earnings. Poor health conditions and higher disability and mortality risks further exacerbate household financial conditions. The effects of child marriage are also intergenerational, as they hinder the creation of human capital in future generations. Poor wage earnings and household savings result in lower tax returns for the State, while poor health conditions lead to greater State spending on health care. Thus, the State economy is affected from both the savings and expenditure ends.
Comparatively, the Arab region lacks the
availability of reliable and consistent data
to measure and monitor child marriage and
its causes and consequences. Recurrent
conflicts and geopolitical issues in the region
worsen the global periodic surveys critical
for cross-country comparisons. Of the 22
countries that constitute the Arab region, only
13 countries had relevant data for the time
period under consideration (2001–2020). For
the exercise of costing child marriage in this
region, the data for the input indicators was
collected and compiled from multiple sources
for the period 2001–2020. The data sources
used for analysis include: (i) demographic
health surveys (DHS); (ii) multiple indicator
cluster surveys (MICS); (iii) labour force
surveys (LFS); (iv) United Nations World
Population Prospects; (v) world development
indicators (WDI); (vi) United Nations Model
Life Table (West Asia Model); (vii) countryspecific
censuses from Arab countries;
and (viii) official statistics of the respective
Arab countries. The present study adopted
interpolation and extrapolation methods to
fill the data gaps between any years.
Globally, the DHS is the largest data source for
population, health, human immunodeficiency
virus (HIV) and nutrition and is internationally
comparable and surveyed in about 90
countries. Some of the Arab countries have
been covered under the DHS programme,
such as Egypt (2014, special DHS in 2015),
Jordan (2017/2018), Mauritania (2019–2021),
Morocco (2003/2004), the Sudan (1989/1990),
Tunisia (1988) and Yemen (2013). The MICS is
the largest source of reliable internationally
comparable data on women and children
globally and has been carried out once or
more in 118 countries. The latest MICS within
the Arab region are: Algeria (2018/2019), Egypt
(2013/2014), Iraq (2018), Mauritania (2015),
Oman (2014 restricted), the State of Palestine
(2018/2019), Qatar (2012), Somalia (2011), the
Sudan (2014), the Syrian Arab Republic (2006),
Tunisia (2018) and Yemen (2006). Although the
Pan Arab Project for Family Health (PAPFAM)
is available in Libya, the study excluded Libya,
due to a lack of information comparability in
PAPFAM with the DHS and MICS, and Oman,
due to a lack of access to the microdata.
Overall, the study covers 13 Arab countries
that have microdata from the latest available
DHS or MICS.
In addition, we collected information on
employment and unemployment from
the WDI, LFS and official statistics of the
respective countries. The total and projected
population data were collected from the
countries’ censuses and United Nations World
Population Prospects, respectively. The study
used the most suitable model life table from
two sets of standard model life table families
to derive a variety of mortality indicators
and underlying mortality patterns for the
estimation and projection of the population
for each country. The data on the base year
GDP in United States dollars ($), annual GDP
growth rate (%), and urbanization (%) were
collected from the WDI. In addition, education
and health-related indicators were compiled
from multiple data sources including DHS,
MICS, censuses, and official statistics of the
countries (see the details in annex table 1).
The linkage between child marriage and
economic growth is not straightforward
because it directly correlates with
some “conventional” economic growth
determinants such as fertility, education,
health and employment, among others.
Wodon and others (2017) outlined five
main channels – health, education, fertility,
labour force participation and decisionmaking
– through which child marriage
impacts economic growth. In their analytical
model, Wodon and colleagues further
consolidated these channels into human
capital (i.e. education and health), as there is
a significant overlap across these channels.
Later, the study by Mitra and others (2020)
also recognized the interdependence
between health, education, economic growth
and other intermediates operating under the
costing exercise of child marriage.
Following Wodon and others (2017) and
Mitra and others (2020), this study used
four sets of parameters (i.e. demographic,
health, education and economic) in the
costing exercise of child marriage in a life
course perspective. Child marriage is like
a silhouette on lifetime outcomes, as it
affects skill formation, health and economic
consequences at all stages of life. In this
study, by saying “life course”, we mean
the estimates are cumulative economic
costs of child marriage associated with
education, health and labour market losses,
which operate at different stages of an
individual life (box below). Moreover, several
other intermediates – such as women’s
decision-making ability and gender-based
violence against women – that influence
economic outcomes were not included
as separate variables because they are
highly collinear with demographic, health,
education and employment parameters.
Nevertheless, within four broad sets of
parameters (demographic, health, education
and economic), the model used in this study
includes other contingent factors such
as age structure of the population and its
drivers, economic status and its predictors,
and the urbanization level of women’s
country of residence. Figure 2 explains
the complete operational (or analytical)
framework of the simulation model and the
parameters used to estimate the economic
costs of child marriage in the Arab region.
While the present study follows the simulation
approach used by Wodon and others (2017),
its analytical framework for estimating
the economic costs of child marriage is
slightly different and adheres to a more
comprehensive procedure. We have extended
the projection of the economic costs of child
marriage for the Arab region up to 2050 with
the base year of 2001. The period 2001 to 2050
is selected considering the working lifespan
of around 50 years for a female married at the
age of 15. For instance, in this model, a female
who married in the year 2001 at age 15 (base
year for this study) is expected to live up to
65 years (up to 2050, a goalpost year for this
study) as a worker or a non-worker. However,
the input indicators are not available for all
countries from 2001. In such cases, the base
year has been chosen as per the availability of
the data. The life-cycle approach.
The study used three key modules of the spectrum-based simulation approach: DemProj, FamPlan and RAPID (figure 2). DemProj stands for demographic projection module in the spectrum simulation model. It provides age-sex population base parameters and their projection for the simulation module. The projection function works on a set of assumptions about fertility, mortality and migration for goalpost years.
The FamPlan module stands for the projection
of family planning parameters. Family planning
inputs are needed to reach national goals for
addressing unmet needs or achieving desired
fertility. For this study, the family planning
module provides necessary parameters that
can predict probable differences in family
planning indicators and their consequences
for the fertility of child-married women and
non-child married women.
Resources for the Awareness of Population
Impacts on Development (RAPID) projects
the social and economic consequences of
high fertility and rapid population growth
for such sectors as labour, education,
health, urbanization and agriculture. For
the simulation model, RAPID provides the
differential probability of socioeconomic
achievements of child-married and nonchild
married input and outcome indicators.
A detailed explanation of these modules is
presented in annex table 2.
The study also differs in terms of its outcome
measures. We have provided macro-level
demographic and health costs alongside the
economic costs (GDP loss) for three different
scenarios. These three scenarios include:
(i) child marriage scenario – a hypothetical
case where we assume all women across
the Arab region are married below the age
of 18; (ii) non-child marriage scenario – the
best hypothetical case where we assume
that all women across the Arab region are
married at 18 years of age or above; and (iii)
overall scenario (as usual scenario) – a case
where the status quo continues, that is, child
marriage continues to prevail at the current
level in the Arab region.
Despite implementing a robust approach to estimate the cost of child marriage, it is important to acknowledge the existence of certain data-related limitations and constraints in this research. The estimation of the economic consequences of child marriage utilizing a macro-level simulation model necessitates a wide range of input indicators, including population age-sex distribution,35 fertility rates, contraceptive usage, mortality rates (such as infant mortality, under-5 mortality and maternal mortality), education levels, health status, labour force participation, urbanization, agriculture and GDP per capita. These input indicators are predominantly obtained from sources such as censuses, sample surveys like DHS, MICS and LFS, as well as vital registration and official statistics from respective countries. In this study, the most recent available data was utilized, and extrapolation of input indicators was performed when required. It is important to note that the consequences of child marriage are intricate and hierarchical in nature. Consequently, any costing exercise conducted through a macro-level simulation model tends to underestimate rather than overestimate the true impact, as it is impossible to include all parameters directly and indirectly influenced by child marriage.
The study presents the national and
sub-national patterns of child marriage
prevalence for the 13 Arab countries
included in this study (figures 3 and 4).
According to the United Nations World
Population Prospects (2022), these 13
countries contribute 80 per cent of the
population in the Arab region.
There is considerable variation in the
prevalence of child marriage across the
region and among provinces within each
country. With 3.8 per cent of women married
below 18 years of age at the national level
in 2018/2019, Algeria is the second lowest
in terms of the prevalence of child marriage
among the countries investigated in this
report. Despite the country’s low prevalence
of child marriage, there is considerable
variation in the sub-national pattern. Across
the seven regions in the country, the child
marriage rate ranges from as low as 0.6
per cent in Nord Est to 6.2 per cent in
Hauts Plateaux.
As the most populous country in the Arab
region, Egypt contributes around 24 per cent
of the population. At the country level, child
marriage prevalence stands at 17.4 per cent
as at 2014. However, there are considerable
variations among the provinces, with Fayoum,
Beni Suef and Giza showing as high as
27 per cent, 26 per cent and 25 per cent,
respectively, and Suez showing just 4.4 per cent
of females married before the age of 18.
Iraq constitutes 9 per cent of the total
population of the Arab region. In terms of
the prevalence of child marriage, with 28
per cent of women married before 18 years of
age, Iraq stands among the top five countries
regionally. Moreover, the sub-national
pattern indicates a significant variation
across the 18 provinces. The child marriage
rate is lowest in Duhok with 8.14 per cent and
highest in Misan with 44 per cent. Najaf (37.2
per cent), Karbala (37 per cent), Thi-Qar (35
per cent), Basrah (33.5 per cent), Diala (32
per cent) and Nineveh (31 per cent) exhibit
more than 30 per cent of women marrying
before the age of 18, as at 2018.
With 9.7 per cent of females married
below 18 years of age at the national level
in 2017/2018, Jordan shows a moderate
prevalence of child marriage in the region.
Jordan also shows a considerable variation
in the sub-national pattern of child marriage
prevalence. Across the 12 governorates in
the country, the child marriage rate ranges
from as low as 3.27 per cent in Tafilah to 15.4
per cent in Mafraq.
In terms of the prevalence of child marriage,
with 36.6 per cent of females married
before the age of 18, Mauritania stands in
second place among all the Arab countries
considered for the study. Besides, the subnational
pattern also indicates a significant
variation across the 14 regions. The child
marriage rate is lowest in Nouakchott-Ouest
at 16.5 per cent and highest in Guidimaka at
57.3 per cent. Gorgol (50.3 per cent), Hodh
Ech Chargui (49.7 per cent), Assaba (46.2
per cent) and Hodh El Gharbi (43.7 per cent)
depict more than 40 per cent of females
marrying before age 18 as of 2019–2021.
The average child marriage rate in Morocco
is 16 per cent as at 2003/2004. Within the
country, the percentage of females married
before the age of 18 varies from 7.7 per cent
in Grand-Casablanca to 29.4 per cent in
Laâyoune-Boujdou-Sakia Al Hamra.
With 13.4 per cent of females married
below 18 years of age at the national level
in 2019/2020, the State of Palestine shows
a moderate prevalence of child marriage
in the region. The State of Palestine also
indicates a substantial difference in the
sub-national pattern of child marriage
prevalence. Across the 16 governorates, the
child marriage rate ranges from as low as
5.3 per cent in Tulkarem to 22.8 per cent in
North Gaza.
With an average of 4.2 per cent of females
marrying before they are 18 years old in
2012, Qatar shows one of the lowest levels
of child marriage prevalence in the Arab
region. However, within the country, the
percentage of females married before age
18 varies from 0 per cent in Al-Shamal and
Al-Wakra to 13.36 per cent in Al-Daayen.
The average prevalence of child marriage
in Somalia is 45.3 per cent, which is the
highest among all the Arab countries
included in this study. Across the regions,
the prevalence of child marriage varies
considerably. It ranges from 12 per cent in
Awdal to 90 per cent in Middle Juba. Ten
out of 18 regions in the country have more
than the national average (i.e. 45 per cent
and above).
The Sudan is the second largest country,
contributing around 10 per cent of the
population of the Arab region. At the country
level, the child marriage prevalence rate in
the Sudan stands at 34.2 per cent as at 2010.
However, there are considerable variations in
child marriage prevalence across 18 states,
ranging from 56 per cent in Central Darfur to
17.6 per cent in River Nile. South Darfur (52.3
per cent), Blue Nile (49.6 per cent), El Gadarif
(47.5 per cent), East Darfur (46.3 per cent),
West Darfur (45 per cent), South Kordofan
(43.7 per cent) and Kassala (40.6 per cent)
have over 40 per cent of females marrying
before they are 18 years old.
With an average of 13.3 per cent of females
marrying before 18 years as at 2012, the
Syrian Arab Republic shows a moderate
child marriage prevalence in the Arab region.
However, within the country, the percentage
of females married before the age of 18
varies from 4.7 per cent in Tartus to 26
per cent in Quneitra.
At the country level, with an average child
marriage rate of 1.5 per cent as at 2018,
Tunisia shows the lowest prevalence among
the 13 Arab countries included in this study.
Even within the country, the percentage of
females married before the age of 18 does not
vary significantly.
With an average of 32 per cent of females
marrying before 18 years as at 2013, Yemen
stands in the top five countries in terms of
child marriage prevalence in the Arab region.
Also, the country shows huge sub-national
variation across its 21 governorates. The
percentage of females married before age
18 varies from 50.5 per cent in Dhamar to
10 per cent in Aden. Besides Dhamar, three
other governorates (Al-Jawf, Al-Mhweit and
Raymah) show a child marriage prevalence
rate of more than 40 per cent.
Both in its conceptual and empirical model, the study presents several mechanisms through which child marriage induces economic costs for a country. Following the assertion made by Wodon and others (2017) that “the impacts of child marriage are large for fertility, population growth, education as well as labour market outcomes”, the present chapter empirically discusses these key indicators, which are also the critical mechanisms for the economic costs of child marriage in the simulation model of the study. Also, with the support of previous studies on the subject from another geographical context, the chapter discusses how fertility, infant mortality, education, women’s labour force participation, and household economic and health costs are endogenous to several other indicators, as exhibited in the conceptual and empirical model used for estimating the economic costs of child marriage in this study.
One of the known determinants of economic growth is population growth. Population growth is greatly influenced by fertility rates. High fertility rates are a key implication of child marriage. High fertility also reflects the high number of both unwanted pregnancies and births. A higher number of births is a mechanism through which child marriage affects the State economy. The study thus analyses the fertility differences in association with the age at first marriage for a thorough understanding of the phenomenon. Though age at first birth is also indicative of the same, the study avoids using it owing to a high endogeneity between age at first marriage and first birth.
Total fertility rate (TFR) is a key measure of fertility that refers to the average number of children born per woman over their lifetime. In table 2, we show the TFR differences across females married below 18 years of age and for those who married at 18 and above. The findings suggest considerable but varying fertility differences for females married below 18 years and those married at 18 years and above across the 13 Arab countries. For instance, in Algeria, females married below age 18 have a TFR of 4.1 compared to only 1.9 among those married at 18 years and above. The largest fertility differences by age at first marriage are found in Tunisia where females married below 18 years of age have 2.5 times higher fertility than their counterparts. Among other countries, Egypt, the State of Palestine and Morocco have more than double the fertility rates among females married below 18 years of age compared to those married at age 18 and above. Despite having higher fertility rates, Mauritania, Iraq, Yemen and the Syrian Arab Republic show lesser fertility differences by age at first marriage. In contrast, the Sudan and Somalia have higher fertility rates and higher differences by age at first marriage. The least differences are found in Qatar and Iraq.
Population health is also a recognized human capital factor of economic growth that expresses its impact both directly and indirectly. Population health directly determines the quality of human capital, while it has an indirect bearing on economic growth through its influence on population growth.42 The infant mortality rate (IMR) and under-5 mortality rate (U5MR), which refer to child deaths below 1 year and below 5 years per 1,000 live births, respectively, are sensitive population health indicators. These are not only key measures of child health but also for maternal and child health care. Mortality among infants and children is higher among adolescent mothers compared to their counterparts married above the age of 18.43 This generates from multiple avenues such as the young mother’s malnutrition affecting the children’s nutritional status, her restricted decision-making regarding reproductive choices and access to health care, limited agency and mobility, and low knowledge attainment on the matters of contraception and sexually transmitted infections.44 The IMR and U5MR differences across females married below 18 years of age and those married at 18 and above are shown in table 3.
The findings suggest sizeable but varying IMR and U5MR differences for females married below 18 years of age and those married at 18 years and above across the 13 Arab countries included in this study. For instance, Somalia has the largest difference (2.6 times) in IMR among females married below 18 years of age compared to those married at 18 years and above. In Algeria, the childhood mortality rates among females married below the age of 18 are almost double those of women who were married above age 18. The rest of the countries have a difference in childhood mortality rates ranging from 1 to <2, with children of females married below 18 years of age faring worse for all the countries compared to women married at the age of 18 years and above. A similar pattern of differences by age at first marriage is also found in the case of U5MR.
Education is a key human capital measure that predicts economic growth.45 Disruptions in the educational attainment of childmarried women are widely recognized in the literature. Females married below 18 years of age are less likely to enter higher education compared to women married at higher ages.46 Lower educational levels for women bring poor social and economic outcomes not only to the individual but to the respective households and the State as well.47 Thus, education is a mechanism through which child marriage may affect the State economy. Table 4 presents educational differences by age at first marriage. Findings suggest considerable but varying differences in higher education across women married below 18 years of age and those above 18 years of age. For instance, in countries like Algeria and Morocco, the difference in higher education among females married below 18 years of age and those who married at the age of 18 and above is 20 and 67 times, respectively, while the differences are the least in Qatar (2 times) and Iraq (5 times). Other countries, such as Egypt, Somalia, the Sudan, the Syrian Arab Republic and Yemen, show higher educational attainment ranging among women married at and above 18 years of age compared to females married below 18 years of age. Differences in the education levels for Jordan, Mauritania, the State of Palestine and Tunisia are around seven times on average, with women married at the age of 18 and above faring better in all these countries.
The workforce participation rate of a population has a direct bearing on a household and country’s economic prospects, while child marriage has an effect on the individual’s participation in the labour market.48 Even so, a male’s labour force participation increases after marriage while a female’s declines. The ILOSTAT, using data from 107 countries, has revealed that men have a higher level of participation in the labour force than females, while this gender gap is worsened for married men and women.49 Furthermore, childbearing also decreases the participation among females.50 Table 5 presents the differences in participation in the labour market by married females below 18 years of age and women married at 18 years and above for those in the age group of 15-49 years for five Arab countries. The findings suggest considerably low but varying differences in the workforce participation rate for females married below 18 years of age compared to those married at 18 years and above. For instance, the workforce participation rate for females married below 18 years of age in Algeria is nearly three times less with reference to those married at 18 years and above. Even in Morocco and Egypt, the differences in women’s workforce participation rate are considerably low for females married below 18 years of age compared to those married at 18 years and above. Furthermore, Mauritania and Yemen also exhibit a lower workforce participation rate for females married below 18 years of age compared to those married at 18 years and above.
Table 6 shows the percentage of GDP lost
due to child marriage across the 13 Arab
countries included in this study. In 2021,
Algeria lost the highest percentage of GDP
(5.1 per cent), while Qatar lost the lowest
percentage of GDP (0.1 per cent). Ten
countries lost over 2 per cent of their GDP,
with the State of Palestine, the Sudan and
Tunisia losing over 4 per cent (4.3 per cent,
4.9 per cent and 4.3 per cent, respectively).
The remaining three countries had lower
than 2 per cent of their GDP lost due to child
marriage, with only Qatar and the Syrian Arab
Republic below 0.5 per cent (0.1 per cent and
0.3 per cent, respectively).
It is important to note that the economic
cost of child marriage not only depends
on the rates of child marriage but also
on the differences in demographic and
socioeconomic outcomes between females
married below 18 years of age and those
married at 18 years and above. Therefore,
Algeria, Jordan and Tunisia will incur
greater economic costs attributable to child
marriage because they have greater fertility
and educational differences across females
married below 18 years of age than those
married at 18 years and above. While, for
countries like Iraq and Mauritania, despite
having higher child marriage prevalence
rates, the relative differences in fertility rates
and education levels between those married
below 18 years of age and those married at
18 years and above are not as high as those
in Algeria, Jordan and Tunisia, thus incurring
lesser economic costs that are attributable to
child marriage.
Given the model used in this costing exercise,
the trends remain more or less the same in
the projected years. In 2050, the Sudan is
projected to lose the highest percentage of its
GDP (5.1 per cent), while Qatar is projected to
lose the lowest at 0.1 per cent. Eight countries
are projected to lose over 2 per cent of their
GDP due to child marriage, with the average
being 4.06 per cent. The remaining five
countries – Iraq, Mauritania, Qatar, Somalia
and the Syrian Arab Republic – are forecasted
to lose less than 2 per cent of their respective
GDP, implying that good socioeconomic and
health resources could help avoid the high
economic costs of child marriage.
The estimated economic cost of child
marriage for the Arab region stood at 3.2
per cent in 2021 and will be 3 per cent in 2050.
In absolute terms (table 7), child marriage
had an economic impact of $40.7 billion in
2021, and this figure is expected to increase
to a cumulative total of $3 trillion by 2050.
Among the countries analysed, Egypt had
the highest economic cost in 2021, reaching
$91.3 billion, while Mauritania had the lowest
cost at $0.6 billion. Looking ahead to 2050,
the Sudan is projected to have the highest
cumulative economic cost due to child
marriage, estimated at $18,784 billion, whereas
Mauritania is expected to maintain its position
with the lowest cumulative economic cost at
$66.6 billion.
The prevalence of child marriage has greater
economic relevance for countries with high
rates of child marriage and fertility, and poor
health-care services, such as Algeria, Jordan,
the State of Palestine, Somalia, the Sudan
and Yemen. Across the 13 Arab countries, the
total GDP estimates presented in this study
align with the World Bank estimates for the
respective countries.
As explained through the conceptual
framework of this study, a part of the
economic cost of child marriage for countries
influences the household as well. Households
with a woman married as a child experience
greater income loss both through wages as
well as excess health-care expenditures.
Earlier, Wodon and others (2017), as well as
Wodon and Yedan (2017b), demonstrated
that the economic participation and wage
earnings for females married at early ages
are significantly less compared to their
counterparts married at higher ages. Wages
have a significant bearing on household
earnings.
This section provides an analysis of the
average annual economic costs borne by
households and the private health-care
costs associated with child marriage.
The findings presented in figure 5 indicate
that households in most Arab countries
face significant average annual economic
costs. For example, seven Arab countries
(Algeria, Egypt, Iraq, Jordan, Morocco,
the State of Palestine and Tunisia) show
average economic costs exceeding $600 per
household, with Algeria having the highest
cost at $1,173 and the Syrian Arab Republic
having the lowest at $37.
The estimated average annual healthcare costs for households also show considerable variation among the countries. The range spans from $292 in Jordan to a mere $5 in the Syrian Arab Republic. Additionally, only four countries (Algeria, Jordan, Morocco, and the State of Palestine) have household health-care expenditures exceeding $100 per year (figure 6).
Child marriage has been shown to have
lifetime consequences for girls regarding poor
educational, health and economic outcomes,
depriving them of fundamental rights and
leaving the next generation at a disadvantage.
The issue has been aggravated by the
COVID-19 pandemic and demands effective
and conscious intervention, especially in the
poorest countries, which exhibit the highest
rates of child marriage. A growing volume of
studies are increasingly demonstrating the
harmful effects of child marriage on varied
aspects of development outcomes. However,
concerted efforts and resources to neutralize
the practice remain inadequate across the
Arab region. To stimulate efforts towards
ending child marriage, the present study
presents the economic costs of child marriage
and its key mechanisms.
The respective economic costs of child
marriage for 13 Arab countries have been
estimated from 2001 to 2050. However, the
timeline varies for a few countries due to
the non-availability of data. The estimated
economic cost of child marriage in terms
of total GDP and the percentage of GDP
lost provide compelling evidence that child
marriage induces enormous and exponential
economic costs for the Arab region. The GDP
lost due to child marriage across 13 Arab
countries is estimated at 3.2 per cent for 2021
and projected to be 3 per cent in 2050, with
the cumulative GDP loss around $3 trillion
during the forecasted period. Country-wise,
Algeria and the Sudan were estimated to lose
the highest percentage of GDP due to child
marriage in 2021, while Qatar lost the lowest
rate of GDP.
On the other hand, in 2050, the Sudan (5.1
per cent), Algeria (4.8 per cent) and Tunisia (4.6
per cent) are projected to lose the highest GDP
due to child marriage if the current rate persists.
The country-level differentials in the economic
costs of child marriage in terms of GDP loss
are both due to the level of child marriage
and endowment factors such as the quality of
health care and the socioeconomic system. It
is possible that, despite similar child marriage
rates, some countries have managed to control
the damage caused by child marriage through
better health-care and socioeconomic systems,
thus reflected in the lower percentages of GDP
loss. And some countries, such as the Sudan,
have not experienced a significant difference
in demographic and socioeconomic outcomes
between females married below 18 years of
age and those married at 18 years and above.
Thus, economic costs solely attributable to child
marriage are relatively less despite having a
higher prevalence of child marriage and inferior
demographic and socioeconomic outcomes in
the country.
At the outset, the study finds that the
economic cost of child marriage is
substantial across the Arab region. Our
estimate (3.1 per cent in 2021 for the
Arab region) is slightly on the higher side
compared to the 1.05 per cent reported
by Mitra and others (2020) in the case of
EMDCs and the 1.44 per cent noted by
Wodon and others (2017) in the case of
South Asian, Middle Eastern and African
countries. The higher side estimate from
the current study can be attributed to a
greater number of components (i.e. direct
and indirect costs) considered for the
estimation. The estimated economic cost
of child marriage in this study accounts for
several direct and indirect costs, as shown
in the analytical framework (figure 2). The
economic cost due to child marriage not
only depends on the level of its prevalence
but also on the economies of scale and the
country’s socioeconomic, demographic and
health policies.
From a policy perspective, the study suggests
that Arab countries can increase their
GDP around 3 per cent by eliminating child
marriage. It is important to note that the
current study does not engage in detailed
empirical analyses of all the pathways
through which child marriage impacts
the economy of a State and intervention
strategies to eliminate child marriage
because they are widely documented in the
existing literature. Along with its conceptual
framework, a synthesis of the empirical
evidence found in this study in the context of
previous literature provides insights into the
mechanisms through which child marriage
induces economic costs for a State and also
provides possible intervention strategies to
overcome this consequence. The critical
mechanisms identified are demographic,
social and health implications. Demographic
implications comprise unwanted pregnancies
and unsafe abortions that alter future
growth, survival and/or reproduction.
Social implications include the loss of
educational attainment by girls who are
married as children, which eventually harms
the exercise of their basic rights, agency,
decision-making ability, earning prospects,
community support and empowerment in
general. Health implications include the
high fertility rates of females marrying early
and higher maternal morbidity and mortality
rates. These implications, endured by girls
who marry early, might be direct or indirect,
as well as monetary or non-monetary,
for individuals and households and are
cumulated at the State level.
In conclusion, the present study advances the
suggestions put forward by Asha George and
others (2020) that eliminating child marriage
also requires addressing the structural
determinants of gender inequality. The
sooner a Government acts to eradicate child
marriage, the greater the economic savings.
Although the financial costs should not be
the only reason for investing in the end of this
practice, it certainly is a paramount concern.
Arab countries must strengthen their social,
economic, population and health policies to
ensure greater gender equality in education,
health and labour market outcomes. Moreover,
financing to eliminate child marriage ensures
human rights.
The present chapter sets out policy recommendations for Arab countries based on the research and analysis undertaken for this study, along with other available evidence. The study advances the premise that Arab Governments need to act on two fronts: (1) eliminating child marriage; and (2) neutralizing the negative impacts of child marriage at the individual and household levels. It is well known that ending child marriage is crucial to advancing gender equality; therefore, Governments must address the structural determinants of gender inequality. Hence, countries must tackle harmful gender roles, norms and power relations by adopting holistic and multifaceted policies, as discussed below.
Child marriage persists in the region, highlighting its localized nature and the need for targeted interventions. High-prevalence countries (over 10 per cent) should develop prevention strategies, focusing on “hotspot” areas (provinces, governorates or regions). These efforts should be accompanied by programmes that challenge harmful norms and discrimination, along with the vigilant implementation of nationwide child protection policies and legislation, including closing loopholes related to child marriage. Recent systematic reviews indicate that cash incentive programmes have effectively reduced child marriage rates in various countries.61 Therefore, Arab countries could consider adopting similar initiatives to address this issue.
Countries should adopt a comprehensive and multifaceted approach to address the adverse effects of child marriage and create an empowering environment for females. This approach should include: (1) strengthening family planning and maternal and child health-care policies to reduce unintended pregnancies, births and avoidable child deaths to lessen the population growth and thereby curtail the economic cost of child marriages in the region; (2) focusing on reducing the fertility and educational differences for girls married before and after turning 18 years old, mainly for countries that experience higher economic costs due to child marriage despite having lower child marriage prevalence; (3) being proactive with educational sector policies to ensure the continuation of girls’ education before and after marriage, particularly alternative learning opportunities after marriage or while pregnant; and (4) developing and implementing flexible labour market policies that support and allow more women to enter the labour market before and after marriage.
To effectively address the problem of child marriage in the Arab region, it is crucial to ensure the collection of reliable and disaggregated data on key indicators. Countries should establish systematic data collection processes to gather accurate and up-to-date information. This can be accomplished by developing comprehensive databases using administrative data systems or conducting sample surveys. Such initiatives will facilitate a deeper understanding of the immediate and long-term effects of child marriage on women, girls, their families, communities and the overall society.
Estimating the economic impact of child marriage is a means to address the short-, medium- and long-term effects of child marriage while adopting a human rightsbased approach. Investing in initiatives to eliminate child marriage not only upholds human rights but also makes economic sense. In this regard, it is crucial for Governments to collaborate with a wide range of stakeholders to secure sustainable funding opportunities and work towards eradicating this harmful practice in the region.